Wednesday, August 10, 2011

Breeann's Father on her Disappearance


SENATH, Mo. -- Authorities have come across three items of interest in the last 24-hours in the case of Breeann Rodriguez, 3, who went missing on Saturday."We have some physical items of interest," Karnes said. "[I can't elaborate] at this time exactly what they are because they are not in direct relation with the case."

Of the items, Karnes said one was found Tuesday afternoon and two were found earlier today, Wednesday, Aug. 10. Karnes said the items cannot be directly connected or directly not connected with the case at this time.

"We can't rule them out," Karnes said.

When asked what lead to the items of interest, the police official said, "Some of our searches happened upon a piece of evidence and contacted me. We secured the area and found some more."
When asked about the evidence sent to the crime lab earlier this week, Karnes said it has come back, but hasn't provided any relevant clues. He also said he is hoping to get DNA off of the newer items.
"They got that back," Karnes said. "So far, none of it has really panned out to be anything."

(Photo)
(Photo)
Authorities are looking for a van similar to the ones pictured in connection with the disappearance of 3-year-old Breeann Rodriguez.
The police chief said the items found over the last 24-hours are discouraging to him, because, "I want to find her alive. I still think she is alive."Karnes said the items of interest make him believe that "Somebody is trying to hide something." He added that he doesn't believe the items that were found may have been there before and been overlooked.
"I don't know if it was searched real thoroughly the first time, but this last search, yes, it turned up something," Karnes said. "We've expanded it from there."

(Photo)
Breeann Rodriguez
(Photo courtesy of NCMEC, www.missingkids.com)
Karnes said the white van authorities were looking for has not turned up, and the only clues they have are some surveillance footage."It is just one of many [possibilities]," Karnes said, adding that the FBI has worked more than 200 tips. "They've chased down leads...every little thing.
"It looks like there may be a trail shaping up," the officer said. When asked in what direction the trail was leading, he replied, "Circles."
Karnes said he has not ruled out the possibility that the new clues are being planted in an attempt to mislead authorities.
"We haven't ruled that out," Karnes said. "That is why I can't elaborate on what it is [that has been found]. We don't want any false evidence placed somewhere."
When asked the current status of the case, Karnes said it is still top priority.
"It's still as fresh as it was on day one," Karnes said. "We haven't changed anything we're doing. We're searching...going back over places and searching again. Keep on keeping on. Never give up. We've got to keep going. We can't give up."
As for the rumors about a white van at Paragould, Ark., trying to lure children in, Karnes said it has been checked out and nothing has materialized.
Rodriguez' parents, Edgar Rodriguez and Claudia Ramos, said authorities haven't told them very much about the items of interest that have been found.

"They say they don't want to tell us something that is not relevant," Rodriguez said as he and his wife searched the grassy area south of Senath where the two items of interest were found. "They are still looking for that white van. As far as the community goes, everybody we talk to says they didn't see anything."


This is an indication that police are not sharing information with the family.  This may be simply protecting them from emotional ups and downs; or protecting the integrity of the investigation. 


"We know somebody saw something," Ramos said. "They just don't want to tell us."

Note that he does not say "I know somebody saw something" but weakens it with "we" as it did not appear that he was speaking for both father and mother.  Also note that he does not say how they know; particularly since the police may not have said much.  We do not know if "they" are the police, or "they" are the somebody (ies) who knows something. 

"We got some new neighbors in front," Rodriguez said. "If anything would have happened on that road, they would know about it. They didn't see nothing. So, I don't know."

Note that it would not have been the neighbors' responsibility to watch a 3 year old on a bike.   Nor is it the responsibility of a 5 year old to watch a 3 year old.  This sets up a scenario of guilt for both parents. 


Guilt will be visible by sensitivity indicators.  


Guilt can come from negligence or it can come from involvement.  The analyst/reader must be cautious for this reason. 


Please note that "nothing" cannot be seen.  If double negatives are used culturally or regionally, communication is viewed the same way.  

The couple said they were not sure how nothing was seen, as the neighborhood enjoys watching children play.

We do not have a quote here but it may intimate guilty shifting of responsibility for not watching the children.

As for the time the child went missing, Rodriguez said his daughter didn't leave the house until after 10 a.m.

"I didn't leave the house until about 10 [a.m.], to go to that auction," Rodriguez said. "Breeann was still asleep when I left.     It had to be after 10 at least. [Ramos] is saying it was closer to 11. She had to get up, brush her teeth, get dressed, and eat cereal before she went outside. It was about 11 o'clock when she went outside and about 11:30 when she went missing. We spend about 30 minutes or 45 minutes looking for her before we called 911.


Note the word "left" as sensitive.  70% likely due to rushing; 30% withheld sensitive or important information.  
Note that the 3 year old had to do these things (get up, brush teeth, get dressed, eat)  before she went outside; this is without mentioning the mother. 
Note "spend" is present tense; "called" is past tense. 
Note that "we" searched and note that "we" called.  Though it is likely both searched, it would be interesting to learn if both called 911.  


The transcripts of the 911 call would be useful for analysis. 




"[Ramos] seen her about five minutes before. Before Austin came inside, she just seen her outside about five minutes before that. You're talking about five minutes, two or three minutes that Austin went inside, you are talking less than 10 minutes [and she was gone]."

"before" appears to be a missing time period.  Its repetition is noted.  
"seen her" is repeated.  
You are talking and you're talking are 2nd person:   He does not say that this is his estimate of time.  




Rodriguez said he was pushing authorities to issue an Amber Alert, but was told the case didn't miss the criteria.   (note that we do not have a direct quote)

"I guess it doesn't even meet the criteria for an abduction," Rodriguez said. "How far can she possibly ride her bike?  Look at where we are looking at. There is no way my daughter was going to ride her bike over here and get lost."


Rodriguez said his daughter never left the street when riding her bike, adding that she was kind of shy.
Rodriguez went missing near her home on Ode Johnson Street at approximately 12-noon on Saturday, Aug. 6. She was last seen wearing pink clothes, pigtails, and was riding a pink bicycle with training wheels.
Authorities say the case is still being classified as a missing persons case, however, the FBI say they are treating it as an abduction.
On Monday, a joint reward in the amount of $45,000 was announced for the "successful return and prosecution of person or persons responsible for the disappearance, if someone did take her."
If anyone has information on this missing child, please contact the Senath Police Department at (573)738-2818, or the Dunklin County Sheriff's Department at (573)888-2424. Tips can remain anonymous.

No comments:

Post a Comment